Repair or replace- 1969 Charger fender

[69bronzeT5]

Thought I'd ask here since I know there are some experienced body guys on the forum. On my '69, I have the original driver's side front fender and a '68 fender on the passenger side that's been converted to a '69 using the original wrecked '69 passenger fender. The passenger fender I think I will use when the car goes to the body shop as it was converted nicely and besides a little rust spot on the inside, it's nice. The driver's side fender on the other hand has me wondering if I should get it fixed or don't bother and find a nicer used/new AMD fender. It's rusty, has a bunch of filler (I can thank my dad for that), a few metal tears on the wheel well edges and a dent on the front edge. What do you guys think?

[tan top]

  I  would look for a real good used fender !
repair the one you have at the last resort !  ,
 if you want to go AMD  I would replace the pair  

[69bronzeT5]

  I  would look for a real good used fender !  ,  if you want to go AMD  I would replace the pair 

That's what I was leaning towards. My friend just bought a pair of brand new AMD fenders for his '69 R/T SE and unfortunately they were more or less $1,000 each after the exchange rate! 

[Troy]

I'd trash it - but I have a few spares... (look up)



Troy

[Mopar Nut]

 I  would look for a real good used fender !
repair the one you have at the last resort !  ,
 if you want to go AMD  I would replace the pair  

  Two years ago, I would have said replace them, but now with the fenders from AMD, there're dented anyway. 

[Charger-Bodie]

Replace.

[Dino]

Replace without a doubt. A good used one would be ideal but I don't know how hard they are to find in your neck of the woods.

[green69rt]

  I  would look for a real good used fender !  ,  if you want to go AMD  I would replace the pair 

That's what I was leaning towards. My friend just bought a pair of brand new AMD fenders for his '69 R/T SE and unfortunately they were more or less $1,000 each after the exchange rate! 

Wait did yo really mean $1000 USD each?  That's wild.  Even the SRP is only $750 plus shipping ($175 for the two pieces).  Any way yo can find a local distributor?  I replaced both of mine and they did take some work but your one side looks too bad off.

[69bronzeT5]

  I  would look for a real good used fender !  ,  if you want to go AMD  I would replace the pair 

That's what I was leaning towards. My friend just bought a pair of brand new AMD fenders for his '69 R/T SE and unfortunately they were more or less $1,000 each after the exchange rate! 

Wait did yo really mean $1000 USD each?  That's wild.  Even the SRP is only $750 plus shipping ($175 for the two pieces).  Any way yo can find a local distributor?  I replaced both of mine and they did take some work but your one side looks too bad off.

That's from a local distributor. From AMD, they are $749.99 USD each which converts to $965.00 CAD. Then you have shipping, taxes etc on top 

[69bronzeT5]

Thanks guys, I'll hunt for a better one.