Unclaimed finds a Vietnam veteran left behind for 44 years

[Drache]

Unclaimed finds a Vietnam veteran left behind for 44 years
Michael Jorgensen's Unclaimed reveals the amazing story of U.S. soldier John Hartley Robertson, declared dead in 1968.

By: Linda Barnard Movies, Published on Thu Apr 25 2013

Special Forces Green Beret Master Sgt. John Hartley Robertson had forgotten how to speak English over the 44 years since he was left behind in the Vietnam War. But he never forgot that he was a father, husband and an American soldier, born in Alabama, shot down over Laos in a 1968 classified mission.

Had Hollywood told the story of the discovery of a long-forgotten soldier, found miraculously still alive in Vietnam after surviving a horrific helicopter attack and crash, it would have involved a dramatic and dangerous jungle rescue followed by a homecoming parade.

Instead, in Emmy-winning Edmonton filmmaker Michael Jorgensen's documentary Unclaimed, we meet a slightly stooped, wiry 76-year-old man living in a remote village in south-central Vietnam who trembles with frustration or pounds his forehead when he is unable to remember his birthday or his American children's names. He is only able to speak Vietnamese.

Unclaimed has its world premiere at Toronto's 20th Hot Docs festival on April 30.

Robertson says he was confined to a bamboo cage in the jungle by North Vietnamese captors and, accused of being a CIA spy, was tortured for a year. Confused and badly injured, he was released and married the Vietnamese nurse who helped care for him. He assumed the name of her dead husband. They had children.

Jorgensen believes audiences in America, where "they don't hold anything higher than service to the country," will "lose their minds" when Unclaimed screens at the G.I. Film Festival in Washington, D.C., in May. "They'll come unglued."

But Jorgensen wanted this Canadian production to screen in his home country first.

The filmmaker came up against enough roadblocks from the military in the making of Unclaimed — especially when it came to contacting Robertson's family — to be convinced that, as one high-placed government source told him, "It's not that the Vietnamese won't let him (Robertson) go; it's that our government doesn't want him."

Unclaimed follows the dramatic quest of Vietnam vet Tom Faunce to prove that the man he was told about while on a 2008 humanitarian mission in Southeast Asia was indeed an Army "brother" who had been listed as killed in action and subsequently forgotten.

Faunce, a soft-spoken man who has suffered crushing loss and turmoil throughout his life, has devoted himself to helping the world's most desperate people. He was determined to make good on his vow to leave no man behind after serving two years in a war that divided America and made him feel like a pariah when he finally came home.

"Tom went to meet him (Robertson) and was very skeptical, grilled this guy up and down trying to get him to break, to say, 'Oh, no, I'm just making it up.' And he was adamant he was that guy," said Jorgensen, who was in Toronto to help host an invitation-only patrons' screening of Unclaimed at the Hot Docs Bloor Cinema two weeks ago and sat down for an exclusive interview with the Star.

Robertson's story seems unbelievable. And Jorgensen was equally skeptical when Faunce contacted him in 2012 about making a doc in the hope it would add muscle to his quest to reunite Robertson with his American family.

Robertson was fingerprinted at a U.S. embassy in 2010. Faunce says he was later told, "There's not enough proof to prove this is John Hartley Robertson. And I responded, 'There's not enough proof to prove he isn't.'"

Unclaimed makes a compelling case. There is physical proof of Robertson's birthplace, collected in dramatic fashion onscreen; a tearful meeting in Vietnam with a soldier who was trained by Robertson in 1960 and said he knew him on sight; and a heart-wrenching reunion with his only surviving sister — 80-year-old Jean Robertson-Holly — in Edmonton in December 2012 that left the audience at the Toronto screening wiping away tears.

She had no idea her brother could still be alive.

"Jean says ... 'There's no question. I was certain it was him in the video, but when I held his head in my hands and looked in his eyes, there was no question that was my brother,'" says Jorgensen.
As for DNA testing, Robertson-Holly has been adamant that it's not necessary. She knows this man is her brother. Inexplicably, Robertson's American wife and two children, who initially said they would like to participate in DNA testing, later abruptly declined to be involved, says Jorgensen.

"Somebody suggested to me maybe that's (because) the daughters don't want to know if it's him. It's kind of like, that was an ugly war. It was a long time ago. We just want it to go away," says Jorgensen. "I don't know. What would compel you not to want to know if this person is your biological father?"

Onscreen, Robertson appears fretful and forgetful and clearly suffering from dementia. He has evidence of wounds and likely suffered debilitating brain injuries.

Hugh Tran, a Vietnam-born Edmonton senior police constable, accompanied Jorgensen and Faunce to Vietnam to act as translator. He said Robertson spoke like a Vietnamese native with no trace of an American accent.

"To tell you the truth, after I interviewed him the first time, I was 90 percent sure he is MIA," said Tran, admitting he had some doubts. "I still didn't believe . . . until I saw the family reunion."
Unravelling Robertson's story was a slow process.

"These memories pop out," says Jorgensen. "I'll give you an example that's not in the movie. The minute he (Robertson) walks in that room in Edmonton, he knows it's Jean. He says to Henry, her husband, 'Oh, I remember, you worked in the drugstore.'"

Henry spent 50 years working as a pharmacist.

Jean and Henry suffered severe injuries in a car crash just days after the reunion and are still hospitalized. Earlier, they told Faunce they are determined "to do right by Johnny" and want answers about why he was left in Vietnam. So far, no officials have contacted Jean's family.

Does Jorgensen believe that the man Faunce found in Vietnam is American soldier John Hartley Robertson?

"It does not matter what I think," he says. "There's no doubt in the family."

As for Robertson, he is back in Vietnam and has no desire to leave, having fulfilled his one wish: to see his American family once more before he dies.

http://www.thestar.com/entertainment/movies/2013/04/25/hot_docs_premiere_unclaimed_finds_a_vietnam_veteran_left_behind_for_44_years.html
https://www.facebook.com/MovieUnclaimed
http://www.movieunclaimed.com/index.php/mnu-trailer

[ACUDANUT]

Great Story. When is the release date on this film ?

[polywideblock]

 just goes to show you never know,makes you wonder you else was left

[Tilar]

I'm guessing there are quite a few others just like him still there.

[nvrbdn]

yep, im sure there is. what a story. i want to see this film.

[71charger_fan]

Or maybe not: http://www.macvsog.cc/john_hartly_rob.htm

[ACUDANUT]

DNA test time with his "real" sister, or other known living relatives.

[polywideblock]

which one of the "we bring everyone home  divisions" would readily admit to leaveing someone behind ? i agree DNA is the only way to be sure one way or the other

[Old Moparz]

If it's true, the guy probably wasn't left behind at all, he probably ended up a victim of post traumatic stress disorder & went off on his own.

Personally I don't buy into the story at all.

[Tilar]

Or maybe not: http://www.macvsog.cc/john_hartly_rob.htm

I'd be suspicious of any web site that uses Domain Discreet Privacy Service.  I'm betting that story is fabricated, probably by people in the US Government themselves.