News:

It appears that the upgrade forces a login and many, many of you have forgotten your passwords and didn't set up any reminders. Contact me directly through helpmelogin@dodgecharger.com and I'll help sort it out.

Main Menu

What is your definition of a "survivor"?

Started by Drache, October 03, 2011, 09:16:55 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

XS29LA47V21

Quote from: XS29L9Bxxxxxx on October 04, 2011, 12:20:43 AM
Quote from: XS29LA47V21 on October 03, 2011, 01:55:43 PM
Quote from: XS29L9Bxxxxxx on October 03, 2011, 01:34:03 PM
Quote from: Drache on October 03, 2011, 09:16:55 AM
Does the car have to be 100% original or can you rebuild/replace some things?

Mainly things like a front end, brakes, exhaust, etc.

If it was under the big red and white tent at carlisle, it was a Survivor :Twocents:


:lol: :lol: :slap:  We agree to disagree, I no issues with my B5 RT 4spd w/ original paint & non-number motor.... anywhere in my head, go find any motor option 69 in any color presentable these days.    I am confused, so now we are the vette set too, please no.  

F3 I am with you bud.  :2thumbs:




Are you suggesting that a car - any car, with a unoriginal motor is a "survivor"?

If so, what has it survived?  :popcrn:

I would rather have a great old body w/ original paint, that has survived all these years, just me.  I guess I have pigeon holed myself into colors, options and nice bodies rather then numbers matching ugly color rusty cars, never had cared that much about that number part.  I drive and beat on mine at times.  So what if I found a factory replacement block and put it in there, some say that is as good as #'s (almost).  75% original paint, that is fairly modified also isn't it?  What about the color that have survived, mostly seems to be the less "desirable" colors?  We are still talking about 40 + year old cars not on every block anymore.  :Twocents:

RallyeMike

QuoteAre you suggesting that a car - any car, with a non-original motor is a "survivor"?

If so, what has it survived?

I would also consider a car qualifying as a "survivor" if it had mostly orginal paint and interior and a warranty engine or transmission.

Of course, any old car that has not met its fate at the crusher is a survivor. I think we are discussing a more elite class of car than that - ie: cars that are intact mostly originally as they were sold when new without major repair, restoration, or transformation. That makes them special, but does not degrade the vaule of cars that have been restored or are drivers either.
1969 Charger 500 #232008
1972 Charger, Grand Sport #41
1973 Charger "T/A"

Drive as fast as you want to on a public road! Click here for info: http://www.sscc.us/

BrianShaughnessy

You can call it whatever you want just as long as you don't call it mine.

   I seriously do not want the responsibility of maintaining a true survivor.

     Congrats and good luck to all that enjoy that aspect of the hobby...    I like to look at them but I don't want one.
Black Betty:  1969 Charger R/T - X9 440 six pack, TKO600 5 speed, 3.73 Dana 60.
Sinnamon:  1969 Charger R/T - T5 440, 727, 3.23 8 3/4 high school sweetheart.

XS29LA47V21

Quote from: BrianShaughnessy on October 04, 2011, 11:10:46 AM
You can call it whatever you want just as long as you don't call it mine.

   I seriously do not want the responsibility of maintaining a true survivor.

     Congrats and good luck to all that enjoy that aspect of the hobby...    I like to look at them but I don't want one.

RallyeMike we are similar in thoughts here or similar I suppose, I am suggesting or trying to say is, I sure like seeing original cars over the years of cars I have seen, I guess because I seldom see any very original, even a 318-838 cars or not rare colors holding presentable all factory paint, ever if some other stuff has been maintained over the years or if they do not belong in some tent at a big show somewhere by some vet set criteria.   Yes Mr Shaughnasty my 1/4 mile gravel drive puts another chip in my car (that would not be allowed in that tent by the way, although B5 RT 4spd orig paint) still gets me ruffled :rant:, but so would a fully restored car.   My thoughts here are in hobby collector thoughts, not towards values or the 1 of X conv 6pac ultra rare, just cool old cars.  For example, local to me, I perceive over the last near 20yrs of friends, shows and youth beating the bushes for cars.... its easy to think generally you know about most cars local to you.  So, just this last wkend met a lady, the original owner, of a 95% original paint 68 RT, very presentable but tired paint, you never know what cars are out there and it is always nice to see them out.  So she has been thinking about painting this car (another color), which she should, its her car, but I sure would not  :coocoo:.          :Twocents:

XS29L9Bxxxxxx

Mopar Definition:
Quote

MISSION:   The first objective is to preserve the nice old MOPARS and gather them together for reference displays to show them as they were years ago.
The second objective is to get all of the owners together for these displays to have fun and enjoy their MOPARS. This is not a club with a membership. Any Mopar that meets the criteria, and would like to attend a show, can sign up. There is not, and will not be any competition within this group.
CRITERIA:   UNRESTORED/UNRESTIFIED MOPARS at least 25 years old. 80% each, of the paint, interior, and drive train must be as "factory installed or applied". It does not mean repainted to the correct color or rebuilt to the original specifications.
We want the display to present each vehicle to best represent it the way it is after it Survived all of these years. Maintenance and normal repairs are acceptable as well as minimal accident repair. Component replacement; such as belts, hoses, exhaust, tires, etc. is expected.
To maintain a high quality display, we recommend replacing components with similar items such as correct tire type and size, correct battery, stock appearing exhaust, correct hose clamps, Mopar belts, etc.

If your Mopar is going to participate in one of these displays, we will ask for two pictures and a short story of how it survived over the years. This will become part of the display.



Corvette Definition (which came first in originating the whole concept of "Survivor"):


QuoteAs the name implies, Corvettes that have never been restored have 'survived' intentional or unintentional loss of original markings, paint or components. Corvettes remaining over 50% unrestored or unmodified may qualify for this award if they remain in a condition that would serve well as an historic guide for others who want to restore a Corvette of that vintage and type. This award is designed to recognize those Corvettes that are "Worn in, but not worn out." A Survivor Corvette is significantly unrestored, unrepaired, or unmodified and useful as a historic reference. It is a Corvette who in the best interest of research should not be restored or improved. Again, as with Certification, the cars are judged against a factory standard and not against one another. The technical portion of the judging is eliminated and instead the Corvettes must complete a 20 mile road test under their own power in an established time frame. Survivors must pass at least 3 of the 4 categories of exterior, interior, engine/compartment and chassis.
Since the advent of this award, there is now a reason for further preservation of Corvettes whose histories and character may have otherwise been lost. Survivor judging is fun and the Survivor Corvettes become a member of an elite group of historically significant cars. Survivor Corvettes are the Corvettes judges and restorers seek out to study.

XS29L9Bxxxxxx

Quote from: BrianShaughnessy on October 04, 2011, 11:10:46 AM
You can call it whatever you want just as long as you don't call it mine.

   I seriously do not want the responsibility of maintaining a true survivor.

     Congrats and good luck to all that enjoy that aspect of the hobby...    I like to look at them but I don't want one.

It has to be tough and I do respect those who are keepers of the flame, so-to-speak. However, do they enjoy their cars? Probably not, from the standpoint of hammer-down, flat-out driving...  :cheers:

maxwellwedge

Almost half of my cars are survivors and I do drive them. Some even have the original tires.

I drive them like they were meant to be driven and have taken a few to the track as well.

I have never cared what the collector or auction crowd thinks is the flavor of the month....I have always appreciated a car that somehow, some way has "made it" after all these years. I have always "pulled the trigger" whenever a nice one comes up for sale.

They are invaluable cars for reference to someone performing a full resto or just a shave and a hair cut. I happily share this info with anyone that ever needs help....another cool aspect of these cars.

I feel better about driving these than I do a freshly restored OE Gold car.....don't know why - I just do.

I beat the crap out of these things back in the 70's.....cut and modified them for racing etc.

Now - I just want them like Ma built them.

Magnumcharger

Pics du jour... :cheers:
1968 Plymouth Barracuda Formula S 340 convertible
1968 Dodge Charger R/T 426 Hemi 4 speed
1968 Plymouth Barracuda S/S clone 426 Hemi auto
1969 Dodge Deora pickup clone 318 auto
1971 Dodge Charger R/T 440 auto
1972 Dodge C600 318 4 speed ramp truck
1972 Dodge C800 413 5 speed
1979 Chrysler 300 T-top 360 auto
2001 Dodge RAM Sport Offroad 360 auto
2010 Dodge Challenger R/T 6 speed
2014 RAM Laramie 5.7 Hemi 8 speed

69 OUR/TEA

My opinion of a what being called a survivor should be is exactly what others have said,mostly orig paint(75 % or more),orig interior,eng and tranny should be matching numbers,and most importantly be somewhat clean and respectable.No rotted panels,major dented panels,aftermarket rims,rotted floors,etc.
Wearable items that needed to be replaced or broke, to keep safely and reliably running and driving.Basically as much as possible leaving everything untouched as delivered from the factory.
I myself fall into two categories,one,I love restored cars,meaning over restored way nicer than they were built.And two,also love survivors as somehow a certain car was able to stand the time and use and stay in somewhat nice original shape.Basically that whom ever being the owner took the care and time to retain it like that.We all see what can happen to cars/trucks after being just 5 years old can be like minor fender benders,replaced windshields from rocks and such,rust attacking them,interiors getting trashed,etc.
With that,I know this is a Charger site and is supposed to be directed mostly at that topic of car,closely followed by other Mopars,so I never really get into how I am into Buicks almost as much,but as the topic in discussion is about survivors,here is one of my Buicks that I picked up the week after Xmas last year.I bought it because of the survivor status it has,and felt I would enjoy taking it out to cruises,nice day drives,etc.
It's a 75 Buick Regal,350-4bbl,tilt wheel,pwr windows,AM/FM,ice cold R-12 A/C,orig paint,14k mile car.The only things changed on this car were the tires,eng hoses/belts,front shocks,and a dual exhaust was changed from the single.From Cummins Buick in Santa Monica ,Ca brought here in 99 or so.
I know it will not appeal to most if at all any of you,but as I said,I love orig cars like this regardless of its  desirability and value.Fun enjoyment to me to own something like this,ntm don't care about driving it around and worrying about it.

69 OUR/TEA

pics...

69 OUR/TEA

pics..


XS29L9Bxxxxxx


RallyeMike

QuoteYou can call it whatever you want just as long as you don't call it mine.

   I seriously do not want the responsibility of maintaining a true survivor.

     Congrats and good luck to all that enjoy that aspect of the hobby...    I like to look at them but I don't want one.

I'm in the same mold. When I was old enough to buy a Charger my 69 was already 10 years old, and there were a lot of punks like me driving them as recklessly as we could. I still have not entirely outgrown that even though the collectors and polishers sometimes seem to have rewritten the rules of "how to enjoy a muscle car". But that's ok, everyone enjoys it their own way.  :icon_smile_big:
1969 Charger 500 #232008
1972 Charger, Grand Sport #41
1973 Charger "T/A"

Drive as fast as you want to on a public road! Click here for info: http://www.sscc.us/

383hp

what about low mileage vehicles?

Drache

There is also a 1st gen for sale here in town for $30,000 because it's a survivor. Such a shame really. The first owner used to drive it on gravel roads (since he lived 5 miles outside off the paved roads) so the paint is all pock marked with chips and small dents. Interior looks really nice though. The guy who owns it now bought it from the original owner. He also owns an unrestored Dart GTS 340 4 speed as well with some nasty rust forming in the quarters.  :rotz:
Dart
Racing
Ass
Chasing
Hellion
Extraordinaire

Ghoste

30k for a 1st gen sounds strong in this market even for a survivor but I haven't seen the car either.

Cooter

All my cars have/had "Survivor" rust issues. Most had "Survivor" ripped up interiors as well..Maybe I shoulda left 'em alone and tried to get top dollar being all that rust "Survived" for all those years. Hmmmm...
" I have spent thousands of dollars and countless hours researching what works and what doesn't and I'm willing to share"

Road Dog

My Charger making it thru High School with me makes it a Survivor. :icon_smile_big:
If your wheels ain't spinn'n you ain't got no traction.

XS29LA47V21

Quote from: XS29L9Bxxxxxx on October 04, 2011, 02:02:51 PM
Mopar Definition:
Quote

MISSION:   The first objective is to preserve the nice old MOPARS and gather them together for reference displays to show them as they were years ago.
The second objective is to get all of the owners together for these displays to have fun and enjoy their MOPARS. This is not a club with a membership. Any Mopar that meets the criteria, and would like to attend a show, can sign up. There is not, and will not be any competition within this group.
CRITERIA:   UNRESTORED/UNRESTIFIED MOPARS at least 25 years old. 80% each, of the paint, interior, and drive train must be as "factory installed or applied". It does not mean repainted to the correct color or rebuilt to the original specifications.
We want the display to present each vehicle to best represent it the way it is after it Survived all of these years. Maintenance and normal repairs are acceptable as well as minimal accident repair. Component replacement; such as belts, hoses, exhaust, tires, etc. is expected.
To maintain a high quality display, we recommend replacing components with similar items such as correct tire type and size, correct battery, stock appearing exhaust, correct hose clamps, Mopar belts, etc.

If your Mopar is going to participate in one of these displays, we will ask for two pictures and a short story of how it survived over the years. This will become part of the display.



Corvette Definition (which came first in originating the whole concept of "Survivor"):


QuoteAs the name implies, Corvettes that have never been restored have 'survived' intentional or unintentional loss of original markings, paint or components. Corvettes remaining over 50% unrestored or unmodified may qualify for this award if they remain in a condition that would serve well as an historic guide for others who want to restore a Corvette of that vintage and type. This award is designed to recognize those Corvettes that are "Worn in, but not worn out." A Survivor Corvette is significantly unrestored, unrepaired, or unmodified and useful as a historic reference. It is a Corvette who in the best interest of research should not be restored or improved. Again, as with Certification, the cars are judged against a factory standard and not against one another. The technical portion of the judging is eliminated and instead the Corvettes must complete a 20 mile road test under their own power in an established time frame. Survivors must pass at least 3 of the 4 categories of exterior, interior, engine/compartment and chassis.
Since the advent of this award, there is now a reason for further preservation of Corvettes whose histories and character may have otherwise been lost. Survivor judging is fun and the Survivor Corvettes become a member of an elite group of historically significant cars. Survivor Corvettes are the Corvettes judges and restorers seek out to study.

Interesting, never made much efforts to find some of this criteria reading here, but good read, thanks, does not change my tainted youth late 80s-into 90s of difficulties finding parts-non cobbled up cars which is likely a strong part of why love clean old survivors.  I remember that bronze RT on ebay I recall  :drool5: at the time, had not seen that green charger above, that is a pretty presentable too.

Drache

Quote from: Ghoste on October 05, 2011, 05:22:54 AM
30k for a 1st gen sounds strong in this market even for a survivor but I haven't seen the car either.



Dart
Racing
Ass
Chasing
Hellion
Extraordinaire

41husk

Technically wouldn't any car 10 years old and older, still around after cash for for clunkers be a survivor :nana:
1969 Dodge Charger 500 440/727
1970 Challenger convertible 340/727
1970 Plymouth Duster FM3
1974 Dodge Dart /6/904
1983 Plymouth Scamp GT 2.2 Auto
1950 Dodge Pilot house pick up

XS29LA47V21

Quote from: Drache on October 05, 2011, 11:17:55 AM
Quote from: Ghoste on October 05, 2011, 05:22:54 AM
30k for a 1st gen sounds strong in this market even for a survivor but I haven't seen the car either.





The red car, if factory paint looks outstanding for sure.  The green charger above is very nice to my eyes, plenty of small dings and such but similar to by blue RT (except mine is not numbers matching as mentioned before  :rotz:).  So is the green charger above still available?

tan top

 as we know !! when cars are advertised for sale  , the word survivor & original has developed new meanings in some for sale adds !!
think some wear items are ok along with some paint say from the 70s maybe early 80 when these cars were daily drivers !!  but i think its difficult to say this much been done  to a car ! & it  is a survivor !! but that much is not !! writing it down black & white !! with out a subject car !!  each cars are different & need to be judged separately !! , course every one sees & interprets things different !!  i know what i'm trying to say i think !!but just read this back & dont seem to make much sense  :ahum: D'oh  :-\
Feel free to post any relevant picture you think we all might like to see in the threads below!

Charger Stuff 
http://www.dodgecharger.com/forum/index.php/topic,86777.0.html
Chargers in the background where you least expect them 
http://www.dodgecharger.com/forum/index.php/topic,97261.0.html
C500 & Daytonas & Superbirds
http://www.dodgecharger.com/forum/index.php/topic,95432.0.html
Interesting pictures & Stuff 
http://www.dodgecharger.com/forum/index.php/topic,109484.925.html
Old Dodge dealer photos wanted
 http://www.dodgecharger.com/forum/index.php/topic,120850.0.html

Drache

Quote from: XS29LA47V21 on October 05, 2011, 03:32:01 PM
The red car, if factory paint looks outstanding for sure.  The green charger above is very nice to my eyes, plenty of small dings and such but similar to by blue RT (except mine is not numbers matching as mentioned before  :rotz:).  So is the green charger above still available?

The paint on the '66 looks nice in the pictures but behind the wheels is pock marked by white dings and chips due to gravel. There are also a few small dents as well.

And yes the green '69 is still available.
Dart
Racing
Ass
Chasing
Hellion
Extraordinaire