News:

It appears that the upgrade forces a login and many, many of you have forgotten your passwords and didn't set up any reminders. Contact me directly through helpmelogin@dodgecharger.com and I'll help sort it out.

Main Menu

Why no Magnum 500s on Hemi cars

Started by Cncguy, January 21, 2015, 10:43:17 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Cncguy

Was looking at old option literature for 69 Chargers, and it says Magnum 500s NA on RTs with  Hemi. Why is this? Could these not handle the power of a Hemi? What were the factory wheel options on a Hemi car?

chargd72

I could take a guess.  The Magnum 500s didn't allow as much air in as slotted mags or ralley wheels to cool the brakes. 

          '72 Charger SE 4bbl 318                          '76 Power Wagon 400 W200                                 2011 (attempt at a) Charger

6bblgt

1968 & 1969 HEMI b-bodies had 15" wheels STANDARD and Chrysler Corp. didn't offer a 15" "MAG" wheel at the time, other than the short lived 1969 "recall" wheel.
1967 HEMI cars could be had with 14" "chrome ROAD wheels" (MAGNUM 500s).
1970/'71 HEMI b-bodies could be had with 14" "chrome-style ROAD wheels" (w/trim rings)

Ghoste


hemi68charger

Now "WHY" they put 15-inchers on 426 Hemi equipped cars is a mystery to me.. Maybe for cruising/rpm issues? I personally would like to know myself.........

Troy
'69 Charger Daytona 440 auto 4.10 Dana ( now 426 HEMI )
'70 Superbird 426 Hemi auto: Lindsley Bonneville Salt Flat world record holder (220.2mph)
Houston Mopar Club Connection

6bblgt

it probably had something to do with a specific tire's limits or load ratings

why do they put E series/rated tires on diesel trucks

hemi68charger

Quote from: 6bblgt on January 21, 2015, 03:22:03 PM
it probably had something to do with a specific tire's limits or load ratings

why do they put E series/rated tires on diesel trucks

Does that mean C-body yachts got 15"? Most I have seen are 14".... guessing I am.......
Troy
'69 Charger Daytona 440 auto 4.10 Dana ( now 426 HEMI )
'70 Superbird 426 Hemi auto: Lindsley Bonneville Salt Flat world record holder (220.2mph)
Houston Mopar Club Connection

Ghoste

Or raising the bottom line of the car?

ws23rt

I'd like to know the thinking as well about why the 68-69 hemi b body's called for 15" wheels?

If less side wall thickness was better (for whatever reason) than why not 16"?

TUFCAT

My guess is with Troy,  I've heard it was done for gear ratio and RPM more than anything.  :Twocents: :Twocents: ...especially since you could get a 3.23 auto with a Hemi.

ws23rt

Would not the tire OD be independent from the wheel dia?  Some people use 20" and more but maintain ride height by the tire they chose.

TUFCAT

Quote from: ws23rt on January 21, 2015, 05:48:16 PM
Would not the tire OD be independent from the wheel dia?

In theory your point is still true today....upsizing the rim 1" changes tire profile. :yesnod:  Maybe it was something about that?  :scratchchin:

FJMG

 :shruggy:
F70-14 OD 26.2"
F70-15 OD 26.9"

I am sure these numbers vary though.

ws23rt

My thinking tells me that with a smaller wheel dia. their is less wheel to tire seating area.  --More likely to spin the wheel on the bead?--
But since the call out was for hemi equipped cars and not 440s it seems like the torque issue may not be the reason someone made the decision. :shruggy:

HPP

Because a 15" diameter tire has more surface contact area with the road than a 14" tire.  This is why NHRA limits allowable tire diameter on the Pro classes. So why not 16" or bigger, well, that was beyond the available performance technology of the day and those larger size rims were regulated to trucks with even stiffer and lower traction tires than what was already on these cars.

ws23rt

Quote from: HPP on January 21, 2015, 10:40:10 PM
Because a 15" diameter tire has more surface contact area with the road than a 14" tire.  This is why NHRA limits allowable tire diameter on the Pro classes. So why not 16" or bigger, well, that was beyond the available performance technology of the day and those larger size rims were regulated to trucks with even stiffer and lower traction tires than what was already on these cars.

The question here is about the wheel dia. not the tire dia. :shruggy: ??

HPP

...and the original question was why no magnums, but it evolved into why 15s?

It matters because wheel diameter relates directly to the tire diameter installed on it.  Look at FJMG's reply, F70x14 vs F70x15. That .7" extra diameter could translate into 1.5" of additional rollout on the ground. That's important and Chrysler engineers knew it.

The whole +1 concept of sizing didn't come around until the '70s when tire manufacturers were improving construction and compounds to allow the shorter tires to have better grip and better lateral g capability.

TUFCAT

15" road wheels (magnum style) were available on Ford products in 1969.  I believe the same OEM vendor "Motor Wheel" made both the 14" and 15" wheels....  I don't know why Chrysler didn't get in on the action?  

6bblgt

Quote from: TUFCAT on January 22, 2015, 02:10:12 PM
15" road wheels (magnum style) were available on Ford products in 1969.  I believe the same OEM vendor "Motor Wheel" made both the 14" and 15" wheels....  I don't know why Chrysler didn't get in on the action?  

Like the Mopar world - everyone puts 15" tires/wheel (or larger) on their car.
The ONLY 1969 FORD musclecars that got 15" Magnum/other wheels (15x7.0" w/F60-15 Goodyear POLYGLAS GT) from the factory were the SHELBY, BOSS 302 & BOSS 429 Mustangs.

The ONLY other 1968-'69 (non-full size) musclecars that got 15" wheels from the factory were the '69 HURST/OLDS (15x7.0" w/F60-15 Goodyear POLYGLAS GT) & Z/28s (15X6.0" w/E70-15 NYLON).*

* & 'Vette "if" you consider it a musclecar (15x8.0" w/F70-15 NYLON).

6bblgt

& somehow I forgot to add:

1969 A12 Road Runners & Super Bees (15x6.0" w/G70-15 Goodyear POLYGLAS)
1968 SHELBY Mustangs GT350/GT500 (15x6.0" w/E70-15 NYLON) GT500KR (15x6.0 E70-15 Goodyear POLYGLAS)

TUFCAT

6bbl, you are 100% correct.  I should have said "some" Fords. ;D  Starting in '70 the 15" Magnum styled road wheels was offered on more Mustangs and even Torino GT and Torino Cobra had them available.  More and more muscle cars were sporting new 15" wheels in '70. Of course we know 15" rallyes came out for Mopar, and even AMC got on the 15" wheel bandwagon with the Rebel Machine in '70

odcics2

 
The hemi cars had the 15" wheels for oil pan clearance.  :2thumbs:
I've never owned anything but a MoPar. Can you say that?

TUFCAT

Quote from: odcics2 on January 22, 2015, 09:17:46 PM

The hemi cars had the 15" wheels for oil pan clearance.  :2thumbs:

That makes sense!  thanks

8WHEELER

Also, the 66-68 chrome Magnum's on mopar's, were offered at 14 x 5.5 only. So I think the width came into play somewhat for the 68 model year Hemi car.

The Ford Chrome Magnums were offered at 14 x 6 and 14 x 7, I believe the 14 x 7 started in 67 or 68.

Dan
74 Dart Sport 360, just for added fun.

6bblgt

Quote from: 8WHEELER on January 23, 2015, 12:03:19 AM
Also, the 66-68 chrome Magnum's on mopar's, were offered at 14 x 5.5 only. So I think the width came into play somewhat for the 68 model year Hemi car.

The Ford Chrome Magnums were offered at 14 x 6 and 14 x 7, I believe the 14 x 7 started in 67 or 68.

Dan

No MAG wheels from Chrysler Corp. in '66.  The '67-'68 chrome "ROAD" wheel was 14x5.5" on b-bodies & 14x6.0" on c-bodies.  IT'S ALL ABOUT THE TIRE! There are many 1970 HEMI b-bodies that came from the factory with "ROAD" or "RALLYE" wheels that were 14x5.5" with F70-14 Goodyear POLYGLAS tires (in '68 the F70-14 was a much less capable tire - GOODYEAR SPEEDWAY)

Mustang did NOT have a 14x7.0" wheel until 1970 & it was NOT of the MAGNUM 500 design.

8WHEELER

I have seen so many 66 Hemi Chargers, over the last 35 years with the Chrome magnum wheels, I assumed they came that way factory   :shruggy:

Good to know on the C-Body size, I have at least six sets of 68 Chrome Magnum's, and all are 14x5.5 so all b-body wheels.

And the only repop size available are 14x6. I have two sets of them.

Dan
74 Dart Sport 360, just for added fun.

6bblgt

Quote from: 8WHEELER on January 23, 2015, 01:30:27 AM
And the only repop size available are 14x6. I have two sets of them.

reproduction wheels are available in many sizes, but not 14x5.5" if that's what you meant  :shruggy:

The "spinner" wheel cover was STANDARD on the '66 Charger.  No other cap/cover/wheel was FACTORY available.

8WHEELER

Quote from: 6bblgt on January 23, 2015, 01:54:40 AM
Quote from: 8WHEELER on January 23, 2015, 01:30:27 AM
And the only repop size available are 14x6. I have two sets of them.

reproduction wheels are available in many sizes, but not 14x5.5" if that's what you meant  :shruggy:

The "spinner" wheel cover was STANDARD on the '66 Charger.  No other cap/cover/wheel was FACTORY available.


That is what I meant, I have many repop sets of 15x8's and 15x7's as well, having four of these cars, I have collected many
sets over the years, some look better with 15x8's, and the bone stock cars I keep stock. My 74 Dart Sport 360 has 15x7
magnum's, Most people think it looks better than the Rallys.

Dan
74 Dart Sport 360, just for added fun.

charge69

Well, I have all 5 original 15" steel wheels for my Charger and 4 new OEM wheel covers that also came on my Charger but, I am kinda fond of the "day 2" look and the Cragars with wider tires.


odcics2

Quote from: 6bblgt on January 23, 2015, 12:39:24 AM
Quote from: 8WHEELER on January 23, 2015, 12:03:19 AM
Also, the 66-68 chrome Magnum's on mopar's, were offered at 14 x 5.5 only. So I think the width came into play somewhat for the 68 model year Hemi car.

The Ford Chrome Magnums were offered at 14 x 6 and 14 x 7, I believe the 14 x 7 started in 67 or 68.

Dan

No MAG wheels from Chrysler Corp. in '66.  The '67-'68 chrome "ROAD" wheel was 14x5.5" on b-bodies & 14x6.0" on c-bodies.  IT'S ALL ABOUT THE TIRE! There are many 1970 HEMI b-bodies that came from the factory with "ROAD" or "RALLYE" wheels that were 14x5.5" with F70-14 Goodyear POLYGLAS tires (in '68 the F70-14 was a much less capable tire - GOODYEAR SPEEDWAY)

Mustang did NOT have a 14x7.0" wheel until 1970 & it was NOT of the MAGNUM 500 design.

68-69 Hemi cars got a 15" wheel for oil pan clearance. In 70 the standard wheel for a hemi was a 14x6".   :Twocents:
I've never owned anything but a MoPar. Can you say that?

6bblgt

Quote68-69 Hemi cars got a 15" wheel for oil pan clearance.
if that was true  - Chrysler could've cranked the torsion bars up for the same effect (& what changed for '70 that this was no longer needed or desired)

QuoteIn 70 the standard wheel for a hemi (b-body) was a 14x6".   :Twocents:
CORRECT!  ..... but if 14" W21 "RALLYE" or W23 "ROAD" wheels were ordered - the wheels were 14x5.5"

ws23rt

If the Od of an F70-14 is 26.6'' and F70-15 is 26.9" as FJMG said that would put the car .35" higher (or just a bit less than 3/8") with the 15" wheel. :shruggy:
The width of the rim would not change the diameter of the tire a relevant amount.

6bblgt

26.9-26.6=0.3" diameter

Coker Tire shows their reproduction Firestone WIDE OVAL tires as:
26.90"(F70-15) - 26.20" (F70-14) = 0.70"

Kelsey Tire shows their reproduction Goodyear SPEEDWAY tires as:
26.51"(F70-15) - 26.20" (F70-14) = 0.31"

Kelsey Tire shows their reproduction Goodyear POLYGLAS tires as:
27.09"(F70-15) - 26.45" (F70-14) = 0.54"

half that dimension would be raising the car from the centerline of the wheel (or the oil pan)

ws23rt

Quote from: 6bblgt on January 23, 2015, 06:52:10 PM
26.9-26.6=0.3" diameter

Coker Tire shows their reproduction Firestone WIDE OVAL tires as:
26.90"(F70-15) - 26.20" (F70-14) = 0.70"

Kelsey Tire shows their reproduction Goodyear SPEEDWAY tires as:
26.51"(F70-15) - 26.20" (F70-14) = 0.31"

Kelsey Tire shows their reproduction Goodyear POLYGLAS tires as:
27.09"(F70-15) - 26.45" (F70-14) = 0.54"

half that dimension would be raising the car from the centerline of the wheel (or the oil pan)

You are right--in the difference of 26.9 and 26.6.  I miss. typed the dia.  that FJMG wrote. :shruggy:----He showed the F70-14 to be 26.2" dia.  OOps. That is what I meant to say.
My point is that the difference in height of the car is minimal and makes me wonder about the motive for giving the oil pan more room as being the reason for the rim size question.

Mike DC

     
The oil pan clearance isn't an issue when the tire is inflated and the suspension is at ride height.  But the factory had to build cars for the 100% real world. 


Imagine driving hard into a curb with both front wheels, like at full speed.  The tire sidewalls will compress fully.  At the same time, the front suspension will be bottoming-out against the rubber stops on the LCAs.  Now the front wheel rim height is the only thing holding the chassis off the pavement. 

With the Hemi oil pan/skid plate sticking down an inch farther than stock, running the bigger wheels was the least they could do.  Even with the 15's only half of that extra inch is on the bottom side of the rim.


ws23rt

Quote from: Mike DC (formerly miked) on January 24, 2015, 07:16:18 AM
   
The oil pan clearance isn't an issue when the tire is inflated and the suspension is at ride height.  But the factory had to build cars for the 100% real world.  


Imagine driving hard into a curb with both front wheels, like at full speed.  The tire sidewalls will compress fully.  At the same time, the front suspension will be bottoming-out against the rubber stops on the LCAs.  Now the front wheel rim height is the only thing holding the chassis off the pavement.  

With the Hemi oil pan/skid plate sticking down an inch farther than stock, running the bigger wheels was the least they could do.  Even with the 15's only half of that extra inch is on the bottom side of the rim.




The extra half of an inch on the bottom side of the rim is not what raises the car. It's the extra .35 in. on the bottom of the tire.

My only point about all this is that the wheel/rim diameter is not what determines the height of the car.  It's the tire dia. on that wheel.
With the F70-14 tire (26.2" dia.) the car is .35" closer to the ground than it is with a F70-15 tire.(26.9")

If the car had an 18" rim with a 26.2"dia tire it would not be 2" closer to the ground because of the rim size. It would be the same.
This of course discounts any difference in side wall flex between the two examples.

With the tires fully compressed as when hitting a curb their would be a slight difference. I wonder if this is what they had in mind when the decision was made about the rim size?

Mike DC

Quoteith the tires fully compressed as when hitting a curb their would be a slight difference. I wonder if this is what they had in mind when the decision was made about the rim size?

That's my point.  If the rim itself gets 1" bigger then that holds the chassis another 1/2" farther off the pavement no matter what.  



We don't think about this stuff.  But the factory does.  Not only that, the whole undercarriage of the car is designed to minimize damage if the whole car gets forced over a curb.

Look at how the stock K-frame's leading edge is curved, and how that affects the side-view angle it presents a curb.  (The aftermarket never worries about this, do they?) 

Look at how the front edges of the rear subframe rails are sloped upwards to the floor.   

There are other things to hit under the chassis, exhaust, radiator support, etc.  But all that stuff is more "crushable" compared to the subframes & K-frame.